Dr. Renée Allen Consulting
Advisory Resource Library · Worksheet
The Build-vs-Buy-vs-Skip Filter™

Is this one workflow even worth automating — and if so, build, buy, or skip?

Once a task earns attention, the next trap is spending the wrong way: custom-building what you could buy, buying what you don't need, or automating what should have stayed human. Answer a few honest questions about one workflow and this returns a single clear verdict — Skip, Buy, Buy & Configure, or Build — with a hard compliance stop on anything that touches patient data without a BAA.

01How this works

You rate one workflow on a handful of honest factors. The filter weighs them in a deliberate order — is it worth it at all → does a good tool already exist → is it truly yours to differentiate → can you actually maintain it — and returns one verdict.

The factors

  • Time cost — how much of your week it eats
  • How standard — rule-based & repeatable, or bespoke
  • Differentiation — a true edge patients feel, or a commodity
  • Off-the-shelf fit — does a proven product already exist
  • Build capacity — can you build & maintain custom software
  • PHI + BAA — patient data involved, and is a BAA in place

The four verdicts

  • Skip — not worth a build or a subscription yet; keep it human
  • Buy — a proven tool fits; don't reinvent it
  • Buy & Configure — buy the platform, tailor it; still don't build from scratch
  • Build — it's core, nothing fits, and you can maintain it

02The research behind it

The build-vs-buy decision has a well-worn discipline behind it — the mistakes are predictable, and so is the way to avoid them.

Geoffrey A. Moore, Dealing with Darwin (2005). The "core vs. context" framework: invest your scarce build effort in what differentiates you (core); buy or outsource everything that doesn't (context). Most build-vs-buy mistakes are core-vs-context mistakes.
AHRQ- and ONC-funded health-IT research on small practices (e.g., Annals of Family Medicine, "low-resource" primary-care practices). Small, independent practices typically have little internal IT expertise and struggle to maintain health IT after it's installed — which is why this filter leans hard toward buying over building.
HHS / HIPAA Privacy & Security Rules. Any tool that creates, receives, maintains, or transmits PHI requires a signed Business Associate Agreement with the vendor. No BAA, no PHI — so PHI without an available BAA is a hard "Hold," regardless of how attractive the workflow looks.

The pattern across all three: buy the commodity, build only the rare core thing you can maintain, skip what isn't worth it, and never let a compliance gap ride.

03What it looks like at three stages

Illustrative composites — not any one practice's numbers — showing how the same instinct plays out as a practice grows. Use them to calibrate your own answers below.

Just starting (solo, <$250K)
Mid-journey ($250K–$1M)
Scaling to $3M+

Almost everything is "buy" or "skip." You have no time to maintain software and no advantage to defend yet — so lean on proven tools and keep your build budget at zero.

Buy
Appointment reminders & no-show follow-up. High time cost, pure commodity, great tools exist. Buy one and move on — building it would be a classic early mistake.
Skip
A custom analytics dashboard. Low time cost today, no edge. Keep it in a spreadsheet; revisit at real volume.
Hold
AI visit-note drafting. High value, but PHI with no BAA yet → held until the agreement is in place.

A few workflows are now genuinely yours. "Buy & Configure" shows up — buy a flexible platform and tailor it — but true from-scratch builds are still rare.

Buy & Configure
Patient-journey nurture sequences. A proven platform fits with real configuration; your sequences are the edge, not the software underneath.
Buy
Pharmacy order & delivery tracking. Important, but a solved problem — buy the tool, don't maintain code.
Build
Your signature intake-to-protocol logic. Truly differentiating, no product fits, and you now have help to maintain it. A rare, justified build.

You have real capacity and a few defensible edges. Build is on the table — but only for the handful of workflows that are both core and unserved by any product.

Build
Multi-agent ops orchestration tuned to your practice. Core leverage, nothing off-the-shelf fits your stack, and you can maintain it. Build.
Buy & Configure
Enterprise CRM / marketing automation. Buy the heavy platform; configure deeply rather than rebuild it.
Buy
Bookkeeping, payroll, e-fax, scheduling. Pure context. Always buy — even at scale.

04Run the filter

Name one workflow and answer the questions honestly — the filter returns one clear verdict.

See the finished result first
  1. An example is pre-loaded — "Appointment reminders & no-show follow-up," already scored for you.
  2. Tap below to see the exact verdict card you'll get — the decision, the reasoning, your scores, what to expect, and a before-you-commit checklist. Then clear it and run your own workflow.
Want to see what you'll get before filling anything in? Tap here for a finished verdict.
Dr. Renée Allen Consulting
The Build-vs-Buy-vs-Skip Filter™

Your verdict

How you scored it
What to expect
Before you commit — checklist

Illustrative decision tool for strategy use — not legal or compliance advice. Confirm BAA and PHI handling with your own counsel before adopting anything that touches patient data. · The Build-vs-Buy-vs-Skip Filter™ · Dr. Renée Allen Consulting

05Playbook — how to use this well

The Build-vs-Buy-vs-Skip Filter™ · Advisory Resource Library · Dr. Renée Allen Consulting — AI-Powered Practice Advisory™
Included with your Practice Advisory Retainer™. Private to you.