Dr. Renée Allen Consulting
Advisory Resource Library · Worksheet
The AI Employee Role Designer™

What does each AI employee own — and what is it never allowed to do?

Before you build an AI “employee,” write its job description. This turns each role into a one-page card: the single outcome it owns, what it can read and do, how much freedom it has, who answers for it, when it hands off to a person, and how you switch it off. It checks every role against a compliance gate and tells you what to fix first.

01How this works

Each AI employee gets a role card. You fill in the parts; the worksheet checks the card against a compliance gate and a freedom ceiling, then tells you what to fix before anything is built.

The role card — eight parts

  • Job — the one outcome it owns
  • Reads — where its information comes from
  • Can do — the actions it’s allowed to take
  • Patient information — none, de-identified, or PHI, and whether a BAA is in place
  • Freedom — how much it does without a person approving it
  • Hard stops — what it must never do
  • Hand-offs — when it stops and a person takes over
  • Owner — who answers for it, how it’s reviewed, how it’s paused

The freedom ladder — four levels

  • 1 · Suggests — drafts appear for you. Nothing leaves.
  • 2 · Drafts for approval — it prepares the finished action; a person approves each one.
  • 3 · Acts, then reports — it does the action and logs it; a person reviews a sample or a summary.
  • 4 · Acts alone — no routine review; you look only at exceptions.

The worksheet sets a ceiling on the level for each role, based on what it touches:

  • Level 2 at most — it handles patient information, contacts patients or the public, changes records, or changes billing or deletes anything.
  • Level 3 at most — internal drafts and messages only, with no patient information.
  • Level 4 allowed — read-only work with no patient information.

02The research behind it

Giving an AI a narrow job, a limited level of freedom, and a named person who answers for it isn’t caution for its own sake. It follows how automation, risk management and medical regulators already frame the problem.

Parasuraman R, Sheridan TB, Wickens CD. “A model for types and levels of human interaction with automation.” IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics — Part A 2000;30(3):286–297 (doi:10.1109/3468.844354). Automation isn’t all-or-nothing. The authors lay out four kinds of work a system can take over — gathering information, analyzing it, choosing an action, and carrying it out — and show that each can be automated to a different degree. The freedom ladder here adapts that idea: a role gets a level chosen for what it does, not one setting for the whole system.
National Institute of Standards and Technology. Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF 1.0), NIST AI 100-1, January 2023. A voluntary framework that organizes AI risk work into four functions: Govern, Map, Measure and Manage. The role card borrows that structure: the owner and hard stops are governance, what the role reads and does maps its context, the success measure and review rate are measurement, and the hand-offs and pause switch are management. The mapping is this tool’s, not NIST’s.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights. Guidance on HIPAA & Cloud Computing (October 2016) (hhs.gov). A cloud vendor that creates, receives, maintains or transmits electronic patient information for a practice is a business associate and must sign a BAA — even when the data is encrypted and the vendor holds no key. An AI service that stores or processes patient information for you is generally treated the same way; confirm the specifics with your own counsel. This is the compliance gate.
Federation of State Medical Boards. Navigating the Responsible and Ethical Incorporation of Artificial Intelligence into Clinical Practice, adopted April 2024 (fsmb.org). The report frames AI as a tool that supports, and generally does not replace, a physician’s judgment, with accountability staying with the clinician. That is why every role card names one human owner, and why anything clinical stops at a hand-off.

The designer turns those into one rule: give each AI employee a narrow job, a freedom level it has earned, and a named person who answers for it.

03What it looks like at three stages

Illustrative composites — not any one practice’s setup. They show how the same card changes as you add roles. Use them to calibrate your own below.

Your first AI employee
A small AI team
Running while you’re away

One role, one owner, level 2. The aim is to learn what “good” looks like before the role has any freedom.

Start here
Inquiry concierge. Drafts replies to new-inquiry messages and offers booking times; a person approves each one. It reads the inbox and calendar, and anything clinical is handed off.
Prep first
Visit-note summarizer. High value, but it reads patient information, so it waits for a signed BAA and a clinician who reviews every draft.
Split it
A role that does everything. If the job sentence needs the word “and” twice, it’s two roles. Write two cards.

Several roles now share inputs. The risks are two roles answering the same message, and one role’s mistake feeding another.

Build now
Weekly scorecard compiler. Internal only, counts only. A sound level-3 candidate once it has a clean month at level 2.
Prep first
Any role that writes to records. It needs a person approving each change before it earns anything more.
Easy win
Give every role its own job sentence. Two roles reading the same calendar should never answer the same message.

At level 3 you stop watching each action, so the review sample and the pause switch carry the weight.

Build now
A backup owner for every role. The pause switch only works if someone can reach it while you’re travelling.
Prep first
A review that has lapsed. If nobody has read a sample in a month, the role is running at level 4 whatever its card says.
Don’t
Raise two levels at once. Move one role one level at a time, and wait out a clean review period before the next move.

04Design your roles

This is where you design your own. Three example roles are already filled in, so you can see finished cards — one ready, one fixable, one blocked — in a single tap before you change anything.

How to use this — 3 steps
  1. Add a role. Give it a name and the one outcome it owns. Three are pre-loaded as examples — edit them, delete them with the ✕, or add your own with + Add a role.
  2. Set its limits. Tick what it reads and can do, say whether patient information reaches it, choose a freedom level, and name the person who answers for it. Then choose its hard stops and hand-offs.
  3. Build the role cards. Tap Build my role cards →. Each role gets a verdict — ready, fix first, or blocked — and a printable card.
New to this? The three examples are already filled in. Tap below to see finished cards first, then come back and add your own roles.
Dr. Renée Allen Consulting
The AI Employee Role Designer™

Your AI Employee Role Cards

Roles at a glance
Role cards

Illustrative design tool for strategy use — not legal or compliance advice. Confirm BAA and patient-information handling with your own counsel before building anything that touches patient data. · The AI Employee Role Designer™ · Dr. Renée Allen Consulting

05Playbook — how to use this well

1. One job per employee. Write the job as a single outcome: “Reply to every new inquiry within the hour.” If you need two outcomes, you need two roles — and two owners. The narrower the job, the easier it is to check and to switch off.

2. Start lower than you think. Begin at level 1 or 2 even where the ceiling is higher. A role earns a higher freedom level after several weeks of review in which you changed nothing important.

3. The hard stops are the real job description. What a role must never do matters more than what it does. Choose the stops before you build, and write them into the instructions you give the AI in plain words.

4. Every role has a person’s name on it. Not “the team.” One owner who reviews its work, can pause it, and answers for it. In a clinical practice that accountability stays with you and your clinicians.

5. Plan the pause before you launch. Write down exactly how you would switch the role off, in under a minute, from a phone. If you can’t describe it, the role isn’t ready.

6. Re-run the card whenever something changes. A new data source, a new action, a new vendor. A card describes the role you built; the moment it reads something new, it’s a different role.

Bring your role cards to our next session. We’ll build the first one in your own Claude, at the level it has earned.

The AI Employee Role Designer™ · Advisory Resource Library · Dr. Renée Allen Consulting — AI-Powered Practice Advisory™
Included with your Practice Advisory Retainer™. Private to you.