Dr. Renée Allen Consulting
Advisory Resource Library · Worksheet
The Patient Acquisition Scorecard™

Find the one channel worth doubling down on

Most practices dabble in six marketing channels and master none. This lists every place your patients actually come from and scores each on the three things that decide whether a channel is worth your time — cost, control, and fit — then ranks them and names the single channel to pour your next 90 days into, with the reasoning.

01How this works

You list your channels and rate each on three axes, 1–5. You don't guess the winner — the scorecard ranks them and tells you where to concentrate. Four channels are pre-loaded as examples so you can see a finished ranking in one tap.

The three axes

  • Cost efficiency — how little it costs to bring in one patient (5 = nearly free, 1 = expensive)
  • Control — do you own the audience, or rent it from a platform that can change the rules (5 = owned, 1 = rented)
  • Fit — does it bring your ideal, high-trust patients who convert and stay (5 = perfect fit, 1 = price-shoppers)

What the ranking does

  • Adds your three scores into one number out of 15
  • Ranks every channel from strongest to weakest
  • Names the one channel to double down on — and why, based on its strongest axes
  • Flags the channels to prune so you stop spreading thin

02The research behind it

Scoring channels on cost, control and fit — and concentrating on the best — reflects what the evidence on trust, referrals and marketing effectiveness actually shows.

Nielsen, Trust in Advertising (2021). 89% of people say they most trust recommendations from people they know — the highest-trust "channel" there is, and far above any paid format. It's why referral and word-of-mouth usually score highest on fit: those patients arrive already trusting you.
Reichheld, Harvard Business Review, "The One Number You Need to Grow" (2003). Reichheld argued that customers' willingness to recommend a business tracks closely with its growth. The channels that turn patients into advocates compound — which is why a high-fit referral engine is worth protecting above almost anything else.
Binet & Field, IPA, "The Long and the Short of It" (2013). A meta-analysis of 996 campaigns found that effectiveness comes from a disciplined balance of a few channels, not from spreading thin — and that campaigns people talk about are among the most effective and the most profit-protecting.

The scorecard turns those findings into one instruction: find the channel that brings trusting patients cheaply on ground you control — and go deep there before you add another.

03What it looks like at three stages

Illustrative composites — not any one practice's real numbers — showing how the best channel shifts as a practice grows. Use them to calibrate your own scores below.

Just starting (solo, <$250K)
Mid-journey ($250K–$1M)
Scaling to $3M+

You have more time than money and no audience yet. The win is a near-free, high-trust channel you can start this week.

Double down
Patient referrals & word-of-mouth. Cost ≈ 5, fit ≈ 5. Ask every happy patient directly and make it easy. Nothing you can buy converts like a warm introduction.
Start building
Your email list. Control ≈ 5 — the one audience a platform can never take from you. Begin capturing it now even if it's small.
Not yet
Paid ads. Low cost-efficiency until your offer and conversion are proven. Don't rent traffic to a leaky funnel.

You have patients and proof. The win is to systematize the referral engine and build owned channels that compound.

Double down
Referral system + owned email. Make referrals a repeatable step in the visit, and nurture your list monthly. High fit, high control, low cost.
Optimize
Organic social. Useful for trust-building, but you're renting the audience — repurpose it into your owned list, don't depend on it.
Test carefully
Paid ads. Now that conversion is proven, small tests can work — but control is high and cost moderate, so watch fit closely.

You're a documented operation. The win is a portfolio where your best channel is deliberately over-invested and the rest support it.

Double down
Referral + reputation flywheel. At scale, advocates and reviews become the dominant, cheapest, highest-fit source. Protect and resource it like a product.
Scale
Owned email + content engine. Compounds every month and costs little per patient — the backbone you control.
Accelerate
Paid ads. With proven economics, paid becomes a lever to speed up — never the foundation.

04Score your channels

List the channels patients actually come from and score each 1–5. It's pre-loaded with three examples — edit them, delete with the ✕, or add your own. Nothing you type leaves this page.

How to use this — 3 steps
  1. List your channels. Everywhere a new patient could find you (aim for 4–8). Four are pre-loaded — edit, delete, or add your own with + Add a channel.
  2. Score each 1–5 on cost efficiency, control, and fit. Go with your honest read — directionally right beats falsely precise.
  3. Rank them. Tap Rank my channels →. You'll get them ordered strongest to weakest and the one channel worth doubling down on, with the reasoning.
New to this? The four examples are already scored. Tap below to see a finished ranking first, then put in your own.
Dr. Renée Allen Consulting
The Patient Acquisition Scorecard™

Your channel ranking

Double down on this one
Your channels, ranked

Illustrative prioritization worksheet for strategy use — not marketing or financial advice. Scores are your own honest estimates, not measured data. · The Patient Acquisition Scorecard™ · Dr. Renée Allen Consulting

05Playbook — how to use this well

The Patient Acquisition Scorecard™ · Advisory Resource Library · Dr. Renée Allen Consulting — AI-Powered Practice Advisory™
Included with your Practice Advisory Retainer™. Private to you.